Ute lost an eye in a disputed encounter

I am not going name names, in fact everything I write is fiction.
Two dudes one a cop are takeing a dart in the garage
when they hear something going down in the driveway.
Maybe one grabs a pipe
They find a black Ute nearby
and beat the fuck out of him and
he loses an eye

Who is wrong who is right
I say the black ute is wrong
because why was he a TO dude
in Whitby at 2 Am
POkING THE BEAR